A pretty standard Sunday Morning Bloody. Pickle, olive lemon & lime. But @ $4 .... you could do worse!

- Caped Otter on Monday January 27, 2020

A thick, rich and affordable bloody mary here. The mix is made from scratch and you can order it spicy or mild. My spicy bloody had a kick and plenty of vodka.

- Dan S on Monday September 20, 2010

I believe Dexter's must have improved their recipe, or at least it wasn't off this morning, as I had a much better experience then the previous two reviewers. The bartender asked if I wanted it spicy (yes!), and I was offered a full glass of beer as a chaser. Still an about average bloody overall though.

- Jchip on Sunday September 19, 2010

Dexter's is the home of the best popcorn in Madison and honestly, it stops there. This place is part of a new gastropub phenom in Madtown. Pricey burgers and pricey taps fill what should be a blue collar neighborhood bar. I ordered the bloody, which was reasonably priced at $4. The mix was very pickley and off. The bartender did mention that she thought the mix was also off, but didn't give me any sorta discount for admitting the foulness. I did ask for a chaser when one wasn't put down in front of me and she happily obliged. However, I was charged $1 for the chaser and I didn't know it until I got the bill. Overall, I would only go here for popcorn because everything else is overpriced and off. It is the twilight zone of neighborhood bars.

- Radio Flyer on Friday April 10, 2009

A decent bloody but nothing to write home about. Weak salad, with only two olives and a pickle. They charged for a small chaser, and without warning too, which I think is a MAJOR Bloody Foul. Sidenote: Very friendly staff and delicious food, but pricier than you'd expect.

- Wagon on Tuesday April 7, 2009