The Old Fashioned

Report as closed

single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starblank Star (4 stars)    Rate It!

23 N Pinckney St
Madison, WI

Breakfast: Yes

Get directions

User Ratings

Joe Havlik: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Star (5 stars)
Spice: single Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: single Star
Cost: single Star
Great taste !!!
- 2014-01-28 19:26:44
libbyrae: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starhalf Star (4.5 stars)
Spice: single Star
Salad: half Star
Size: single Star
Strength: single Star
Cost: single Star
This ties with Genna's i think, even though they don't have build-your-own. if they did, Old Fashioned would win (but it would be sad for Genna's, b/c they really couldn't compete then, w/ not having breakfast). Old Fashioned's bloodys have a great amount of horseradish, which i prefer over hot sauce personally. Their salad could use more substance (but i like a LOT of salad - it should legitimitly BE a salad w/ alcohol in my mind). And, of course, huge benefit of Old Fashioned is that they have amazing brunch and lunch as well. so great!
- 2009-09-24 23:15:50
Jchip: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starblank Star (4 stars)
Spice: blank Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: single Star
Cost: single Star
I enjoyed the great salad on their Wisconsin Bloody, but I thought the drink itself was a little bland.
- 2009-08-03 21:28:10
Dan S: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starblank Star (4 stars)
Spice: half Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: single Star
Cost: half Star
The Wisconsin Bloody is a small meal. It has beef jerky, a pickled egg, cheese curds, asparagus..., all locally produced. I think it's a bit heavy on horseradish though.
- 2009-06-01 10:29:16
Sara: single Starsingle Starsingle Starblank Starblank Star (3 stars)
Spice: half Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: half Star
Cost: blank Star
Not tomato-y enough for me.
- 2008-10-20 21:35:06
Marisa: single Starsingle Starsingle Starblank Starblank Star (3 stars)
Spice: half Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: half Star
Cost: blank Star
Try the ginger bloody mary... the old fashioned bloody is waayyy to horseradish-ey... but good salad bar. 6.50 for a bloody there.
- 2008-07-18 11:34:38
Dan S: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starhalf Star (4.5 stars)
Spice: half Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: single Star
Cost: single Star
Almost a five star bloody. I thought it was lacking a little in flavor. The horseradish dominated the flavor. They also have a ginger bloody mary - but didn't try that one.
- 2008-06-05 16:32:23
lisa: single Starsingle Starsingle Starsingle Starhalf Star (4.5 stars)
Spice: single Star
Salad: single Star
Size: single Star
Strength: half Star
Cost: single Star
You have to love the Wisconsin tradition of a beer chaser. And they have _amazing_ cheese curds.
- 2008-03-13 20:29:53

Photos

Share your pics for this location by tagging them on flickr.com with this machine tag:

flickr